Shelter Island Census Designated Place
Congdons Creek
Passionist Monastery
Congdons Point
Shelter Island
Little Cedar Island
Saint Mary's Episcopal Cemetery
Saint Marys Episcopal Church
Coecles Harbor Marina and Boatyard
Smith Cove
Shelter Island Presbyterian Church
South Ferry Hills
Fresh Pond
Shelter Island Presbyterian Church Burial Ground
Nichols Cemetery
Shelter Island High School
Shelter Island Cemetery
Coecles Harbor
Shelter Island
Neck Point
Shelter Island Windmill
Shelter Island Fire District Headquarters Station 1
Shelter Island Ambulance
Dickerson Creek
Wards Point
Menantic Creek
Little Ram Island
Cedar Island
Shelter Island Fire District Cobbetts Lane Station 2
Island Boatyard
Quaker Cemetery
Lower Beach
Cedar Island Cove
Upper Beach
Gardiners Creek
Shelter Island Heights Census Designated Place
West Neck Harbor
Our Lady of the Isle Cemetery
Shell Beach
Mashomack Preserve
Montclair Colony
Gardiners Bay Country Club
West Neck Point
Pomps Point
Dering Harbor Marina
West Neck Creek
Dering Harbor
Cornelius Point
Ram Island
Sungic Point
Chase Creek
Silver Beach
Dering Harbor Village Hall
Shelter Island Yacht Club
Shanty Bay
Dering Harbor
Shelter Island Country Club
Chequit Point
Shelter Island Fire District Shelter Island Heights Station 3
Shelter Island Heights
West Neck Bay
Shelter Island Heights Historic District
Dering Point
Reel Point
Ram Island Yacht Club
Our Lady of the Isle Church
West Neck
Majors Point
Hay Beach Point
Crescent Beach
Ram Head
Majors Harbor
Gibsons Beach
Nicoll Point
Westmoreland
Eastern Long Island Heliport
Crab Creek Point
Crab Creek
Shelter Island Sound
Mashomack Point
Jennings Point
Sand Spit
Camp Quinipet